Evans, Nicholas


Evans, Nicholas, The present and the past in medieval Irish chronicles, Studies in Celtic History 27, Woodbridge: Boydell Press, 2010.

  • Book/Monograph
Citation details
The present and the past in medieval Irish chronicles
Boydell Press
Abstract (cited)
Ireland has the most substantial corpus of annalistic chronicles for the early period in western Europe. They are crucial sources for understanding the Gaelic world of Ireland and Scotland, and offer insights into contacts with the wider Christian world. However, there is still a high degree of uncertainty about their development, production, and location prior to 1100, which makes it difficult to draw sound conclusions from them. This book analyses the principal Irish chronicles, especially the Annals of Ulster, Annals of Tigernach, and the Chronicum Scotorum, identifying their inter-relationships, the main changes to the texts, and the centres where they were written in the tenth and eleventh centuries - a significant but neglected period. The detailed study enables the author to argue that the chroniclers were in contact with each other, exchanging written notices of events, and that therefore the chronicle texts reflect the social connections of the Irish ecclesiastical and secular elites. The author also considers how the sections describing the early Christian period (approximately 431 to 730 AD) were altered by subsequent chroniclers; by focussing on the inclusion of material on Mediterranean events as well as on Gaelic kings, and by comparing the chronicles with other contemporary texts, he reconstructs the chronicles' contents and chronology at different times, showing how the accounts were altered to reflect and promote certain views of history. Thus, while enabling readers to evaluate the sources more effectively, he also demonstrates that the chronicles were sophisticated and significant documents in themselves, reflecting different facets of contemporary medieval society and their shifting attitudes to creating and changing accounts of the past.
Subjects and topics
Irish annals
textual criticism
[1] “Introduction”
[2] “The ‘Annals of Ulster’, 912–1100”
[3] “The characteristics of the ‘Annals of Tigernach’ and Chronicum Scotorum
[4] “The Clonmacnoise group 912–1100 and its relationship with the ‘Chronicle of Ireland’”
[5] “Shared items in AU and the Clonmacnoise-group, AD 912–1100”
[6] “The restructuring of the past in the ‘Chronicle of Ireland’”
[7] “The chronology of the ‘Chronicle of Ireland’, 431–730”
[8] “The original chronology of the Irish chronicles, circa 550–730”
[9] “The Clonmacnoise-group redaction of medieval history AD 431–730 in the tenth and eleventh centuries”
[10] “Conclusion: Chronicling medieval Ireland”
Dennis Groenewegen